After five months and over 185 wines, Chile and Argentina still offer up surprises.
We set off to find great-tasting, value, soulful wines from Chile and Argentina, and have found a few (not as many as we would have hoped!) and have confirmed that Argentina is a great place to live for value-seeking wine-geeks. For those of you concerned for my health, please rest assured that most of the 180 wines were simply “tasted,” either when I served as a wine judge or when we met with potential clients at wineries, and involved very little actual alcohol consumption! Wine tasting, less glamorous than it sounds, is performed according to industry standards, and the ones I follow were developed by the Court of Master Sommeliers and involve visually inspecting, smelling, tasting, and yes, spitting out the wine.
Argentina has put most of its focus on selling Malbec to Americans, and is working under the misguided assumptions that the market for high-end wines is rapidly increasing in the U.S. and that the style that is selling best at the moment is the one everyone should produce. Malbec’s continued popularity for the export market has resulted in a decrease in unique, terroir-driven wines and an increase in fruit-forward, enjoyable and interchangeable wines. This is great for brand Malbec, but is sad for anyone looking to try more of the old-fashioned, rustic Malbecs. I am among a growing group who are beginning to fear that this may result in Malbec going the way of Merlot or Chianti and becoming a victim of its own success. Just last week, a winery told me that they’re making Malbec in a very fruit-forward style “because it’s what Americans want.” I bit my tongue and simply responded, “Yes, some Americans.” I believe there is and will continue to be a market for these fruity, internationalized wines, but don’t expect it to continue to grow as steadily as it has in the past as wine drinkers move to the next varietal of the moment.
However, there are still some interesting Malbecs coming out of Mendoza that give you a sense for the very unique Mendoza terroir, some very exciting Malbec-based blends, and a few surprises. It just takes a bit more searching to find them, as they are the exception to the rule. Following are a few wines from The Annual Wine Republic Tasting 2010 which I had the pleasure of rating as one of the seven judges as we samples some of Argentina’s best. The wines below are generally still a good value that you can find in the US, either at your local wine shop or through online wine retailers:
- Malbec-based blend: Alta Vista Atemporal 2007 ($18) – if you’re just going to try one new wine, try this one. I really enjoy the Alta Vista style, whose French influence is reflected in the manner in which they highlight the Mendoza terroir and present very well balanced and interesting wines.
- Two Malbecs to try: Hacienda del Plata Malbec Zagal 2008 ($14), Kaiken Ultra Malbec 2007 ($20). The Zagal is produced by a family winery with a gentelman-cowboy background, and includes a bit more of a rustic style, which is a very nice surprise. Kaiken is a cross-Andean wine, produced by the Montes group of Chile, which may make it a bit easier to find at your local wine shop.
- Malbec splurge: Ruca Malen Kinien Malbec 2007 ($35). Ruca Malen is a midsized winery (approx 50,000 cases) that produces excellent wines, especially within their Kinien line. Ruca Malen wines have a refreshing funk (oxymoron?) that add another layer of complexity, and which is in great harmony in the Kinien Malbec. Their Ruca Malen Malbec was not included in the competition, though is still a very enjoyable, great value wine.
- Surprise – try a Tempranillo: O.Fournier Urban Uco Tempranillo 2008 ($11). A friend and chocolatier has conducted some interesting taste experiments pairing this wine with chocolate: The Tempranillo Experiment
- Money-to-burn splurge: Benegas Lynch Meritage 2006 ($48) or Catena Zapata Estiba Reservada 2004 (approx $150, exclusively for sale in Argentina.) Mr. Parker, upon reviewing this wine (100% Cabernet Sauvignon), noted that it “is a wonderful wine that deserves to be compared to the best of Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon.” These two are not great value wines, but are enjoyable, nonetheless, especially when they’re on someone else’s dime!



